“The Rare Chance”

CathedralSomething I appreciate about the thinking of Seth Godin is that he finds a way to blend the possible and the practical.  And he crafts some great one-liners in the process.  A recent post of his, “On Building a Cathedral,” is a great example of this.

He begins with a simple premise:

If you’re in need of a gathering place, a dry, functional, centrally located facility for your folks to meet, a cathedral is probably way more than you need. It’s far more expensive to build and maintain and not optimal in delivering what’s required.

But what if this building needs to fill other functions as well?

And then he gives a short list of “perhaps…” statements to get you thinking.

He closes by turning things around using one of his most common approaches: talking about the tendency of organizations to “race to the bottom” in order to succeed.  And then he says this:

The thing we’re working on is a rare chance to contribute something far more than the least we could get away with.

Such a great quality: to call you out and to inspire you at the same time.  How great it would be if we all could contribute “more than the least we could get away with.”

(image of Saint Paul’s from businessinsider.com)

Posted in Internet, Organizations and Institutions | Tagged | Leave a comment

Reading in Lent

Great DivorceOne of the practices I’m trying to hold to during the Lenten season is the reading of shorter books.  Small thing, I know, but it feels somehow fitting.  The season started as I finished up Zena Hitz’s Philosophers Look at Religious Life, which was far from a tome.  From there, I made my way (back) to The Great Divorce by C. S. Lewis.  It’s a book that I have read a few times over the years and think about often.  It’s not the kind of book one read’s flippantly.   Till We Have Faces feels much the same way, though The Great Divorce has more payoff throughout the book.

Funny enough, the preface of The Great Divorce is almost worth the whole price of admission.  He starts with the thought that we can’t have it all, that life will ultimately boil down to some kind of either-or choice that is not a fallacy.  Lewis writes:

You cannot take all luggage with you on all journeys; on one journey even your right hand and your right eye may be among the things you have to leave behind.

A nice nod to the Sermon on the Mount there.  At the end of the same paragraph Lewis writes:

Good, as it ripens, becomes continually more different not only from evil but from other good.

Which feels like a key Lewisian thought in a nutshell.

There are so many great moments in the story’s 146 pages.  So many honest questions asked and sobering responses given.  I hate to take too many of them out of context, which the narrator’s guide is also concerned about, it seems.  But here’s one of my all-time favorite conversation/quotes from the book (which hopefully doesn’t suffer from a lack of context here):

‘Every natural love will rise again and live forever in this country: but none will rise again until it has been buried.’

‘The saying is almost too hard for us.’

‘Ah, but it’s cruel not to say it.  They that know have grown afraid to speak.  That is why sorrows that used to purify now only fester.’

Posted in Books, Faith | Tagged | Leave a comment

Remembrance Part Two.Five

Last week as I was thinking the second thing to remember from Erik Varden (remember you were once a slave in Egypt), a song from long ago came to mind.  A bit of context from an odd source first, though.

A couple of weeks ago, Russell Moore posted a fun reflection on the contemporary Christian music industry (inspired by a recent book about the topic, which I really should check out).  In the article, Moore traces his agreements and disagreements with the author’s attempt to trace cultural trends through the lens of CCM from the 1970s til today.  As others have pointed out, it is fun seeing what artists Moore mentions, fun seeing what overlap is or isn’t there.  One of the best moments from the piece:

Contemporary Christian music, flawed as any human endeavor is, was a positive force in my life. The music of Amy Grant and Rich Mullins went with me through an adolescent spiritual crisis and are probably part of the reason I came out of it more Christian than I went in. I’m amazed by how much of my incipient theology—convictions I teach to this day—was taught to me by Petra lyrics. I have never, not once in 30 years of ministry, preached Romans 6 without hearing their “Dead Reckoning” song in my mind.

I learned how to read biblical narrative Christologically, how to understand parable and poetry and paradox, from the lyrics of Michael Card. I might be embarrassed to tell you how often, in the middle of dark times, what strengthens me are words like “Where there is faith / There is a voice calling, keep walking / You’re not alone in this world” or “I’ll be a witness in the silences when words are not enough” or “God is in control / We will choose to remember and never be shaken.” None of that may be rock-and-roll, but I will die believing that God gave that to me.

I’m always a little surprised in reflections on CCM that don’t mention Steven Curtis Chapman, whose music really has spanned decades.  His most recent album, Still, is a quality piece of work that picks up on some of SCC’s long-term themes while also folding in some greater eschatological hope.

All of this to say that SCC’s “Remember Your Chains” came to mind as I was thinking about Varden’s challenge to us to remember what God has saved us from.  This clip of SCC singing the song looks and feels like it’s from another world, which, I suppose, it is.  The song is from his Heaven in the Real World album, which was the first “brand new” SCC album I ever bought, I think.  If the hairstyle and fashion throw you off, just close your eyes and listen to the song and remember.

Posted in Books, Church, Faith, Music | Leave a comment

Remembrance Part Two

Varden LonelinessFor me, most Lenten seasons start with the “bang” of Ash Wednesday but quickly fall into a slough of messy hopes and habits.  That’s a cost of being interested in the church calendar as a member of a church that doesn’t do much with the calendar.  But I’m also not a big “give things up” kind of guy. Which brings me to this comment by Erik Valden in the chapter of The Shattering of Loneliness that deals with the “dying daily” pointed at in Ash Wednesday:

A monastery is a specialist environment designed to support perseverance over time.  It is a place where the depths can be faced in Jesus Christ.  It stands by its very existence as an extended hand of friendship to all who have looked into those depths and found them fearful.  Monks and nuns hope, by their lives, by their prayers, to invite fellow seekers to look up, to find their hearts touched by a deep remembrance of God’s original caress.  To remember this is to awaken to hope.  And to find comfort the does not deceive.

And so a comfort and a challenge: the comfort that somewhere Christians are able to live into a way of life that can be difficulty to grasp and seemingly impossible to maintain, and the challenge that it’s possible to do such a thing outside of the rhythms of a monastery.

The church can and should, of course, be a picture of this reality, too.  Something about perseverance was, perhaps, part of the draw and the reason to stay.  From the book’s introduction, Varden writes:

The Church became for me an inspirer of remembrance.  It permitted me to read my banal, sometimes squalid life into a narrative of redemption that not only reaches back to time’s beginning but remembers forward, to eternity.  To stay within that narrative’s crux is to hear, sometimes with terrifying clarity, the desolate cries of mankind; to hear, too, the rasping voice of evil; and that, not vaguely round about, but in one’s heart.  One can only persevere in such hearing by attending, at the same time, to another, discreet but ordering voice that speaks “It is accomplished!”  It manages, by harmonic genius, to fathom the violent cries of “Crucify!’ and the angelic ‘Hosanna!’ in a single chord that rises out of dissonance towards unheard beauty.

+ + + + + + +

The second “remembrance” that Varden writes about it the Old Testament to “remember you were a slave in Egypt.”  He spends much of the chapter’s early section in Deuteronomy while also reminding us of our own live:

Insofar as I enter the logic and flow of biblical remembrance, I am made aware that I, who today may have attained some degree of freedom, was not always free.  I am asked not to forget how the transition came about, to see my desert journey as a process of redemption. Only by recalling what I was  can I acknowledge what, by grace, I have become.  Forgetfulness threatens to envelop us, however.  The smog of perceived entitlement obscures grateful retrospect.  It happened in Canaan, where Israel, God’s vassal, developed, soon enough, a notion of itself as landowner.  It easily happens in each of our lives.  We claim rights where grace is at work, and so are made ungracious.  We inhale the chief intoxicant of spiritual life: self-righteous ingratitude.  

Varden makes the connection, then with Jesus’ command to remember via the Last Supper, which is a retelling of the Exodus event that gave the Hebrew people their freedom.  He reminds the reader that Paul in his letters would often remind his readers of his own past and of the constant call to the freedom that Christ brings (and that we in our immaturity too often try to thwart).  Before moving into the story of Mary of Egypt, Varden concludes:

Each of us will have his or her own story of deliverance.  We should not make a fetish of it, nor proclaim it indiscriminately, but we are not to forget.  I may claim citizenship of Jerusalem above (cf. Philippians 3:20); but if I forget where I came from, the wastelands I have passed through, I forfeit my right to call it ‘home’.  For to remain in that place of light, I must know I am a guest brought in out of darkness.  I must learn to respond to grace with grace, to take nothing for granted, and so able to receive all as gift.

Posted in Books, Church, Faith, Life in the Fifth Act, Scripture | Leave a comment

Peter’s Clarifying Question

Ah, Peter.  It is always good to be specific when you ask a question that is easily misinterpreted!  Otherwise, a clarifying question is necessary.  This Sunday’s FoxTrot by Bill Amend:

FoxTrot Clarifying Question(image from gocomics.com)

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Wilderness Training

The first (and perhaps primary) image of Lent is of Jesus’s temptation in the wilderness.  It’s a moment in time that three of the four Gospels capture, a hinge moment between Jesus’ baptism by John and the beginning of His ministry.  Unlike the Matthew and Luke, Mark keeps it brief:

At once the Spirit sent him out into the wilderness, 13 and he was in the wilderness forty days, being tempted  by Satan. He was with the wild animals, and angels attended him. [Mark 1:12-13]

Hans Boersma recently posted a piece about Jesus’ time of temptation in the wilderness.  He starts:

It is meet and right that Lent should start with Matthew 4. Its first sentence sums up not just Lent but the entire Christian life. “Then was Jesus led up of the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted by the devil” (Matt. 4:1). We may apply this to ourselves: “Then was I led up of the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted by the devil.” Our brief span of life is the wilderness. The Spirit himself has led us here. His purpose is that we be tempted by the devil.

From the get-go, Boersma pulls no punches: that last sentence feels a little reductionistic to me.  But then he unpacks things a bit more:

This sentence contains a great mystery: Why would God himself—the Holy Spirit—lead us into this world so that we might be tempted by the devil? I cannot solve this mystery, for God’s mysteries are not like puzzles. They cannot be solved; they are meant to be lived instead.

I like that last sentence much more.  It reminds me of a quote from somewhere in my past, when someone suggested that we live out lives as answers to the big questions.

Following the lines of Matthew and Luke, Boersma brings in the three temptations Jesus faces: provision, protection, and power, or as he later paraphrases for us: My bread, my safety, my status.

The whole piece by Boersma is worth the read.  It’s a sobering reminder that life in the wilderness is a picture of life in this world including but beyond a season like Lent.  And he reminds us that Jesus is in the wilderness with us.  I would add that, in this part of the Biblical Story, we are in this wilderness world together, which is no small thing either.

A closing line from the piece:

Letup comes only after the forty days are over—at the end of our worldly wilderness. This is the last verse of the temptation narrative: “Then the devil leaveth him, and behold, angels came and ministered unto him” (Matt. 4:11). Yes, temptation will give way to consolation, the wilderness will make room for paradise, and the devil will shrink back when angels come to minister. This is the great promise that the story holds out to us: Temptations will certainly end.

Later this week I’ll post my second reflection on Varden’s The Shattering of Loneliness as the season leading up to Easter continues.

Posted in Church, Faith, Life in the Fifth Act | Leave a comment

Doubts and Ladders

This week my department started discussing Matthew Lee Anderson’s Called in Questions, which is about the importance of asking questions in the Christian life.  We had a good conversation about the first chapter or so, with opinions about the place of questioning in and of the faith covering the spectrum.

This week over at Christianity Today, Brad East (of Abilene Christian University) posted a piece about doubt and the asking of questions that has been a nice continuation of the conversation for me.  East builds a great “argument” about the odd place of doubt in the life of the church and faith and does a quality redirect asserting another way to think about the issue: not just faith but faithfulness to a person, Jesus.  A quality quote:

What makes Christianity hard is faith, albeit not in the sense many of us expect. For too many Christians raised in the church, faith means mental and emotional certainty, and so the Christian life is defined as believing as hard as you can in difficult things. In this model, when a feral question nudges its nose into the tent, you’re left with only two options: Kick it out by somehow believing harder or accept that your faith is fraudulent and give it up. Having faith means I must work myself into a lather believing weird things that “modern” people in a “scientific” age find incredible. With that as the alternative, no wonder doubt looks attractive!

But faith is not this desperate maintenance of internal certainty. It is just as accurately (maybe even better) translated as faithfulness. To have faith is to keep faith, to maintain fidelity to God, to trust him and become trustworthy in turn. What is universally hard about being a Christian is being faithful to the Lord no matter one’s circumstances.

As always, the whole piece is worth a reading.  It’s both clarifying and encouraging.

Posted in Church, Faith, Life in the Fifth Act, Teaching | 1 Comment

Getting Somewhere Together

Besides the song that I shared yesterday, there’s been one other song that’s been on my mind.  And it’s a song that has been around for most of my life.

I remember when Tracy Chapman won a Grammy for “Fast Car” back in 1989.  It was odd seeing a not-#1 song by a new artist win a Grammy (at least for me).  But the song was catchy . . . so catchy that it’s stuck around radio and in my head these last three decades.  I don’t watch the Grammys anymore, and I only listened to country music when my former neighbors had it on in the background when we were playing cards.  I knew that Luke Combs had done a cover of the song and that it had done quite well.  When I heard that Chapman and Combs had performed it on this year’s Grammys, I was interested in seeing the performance, which (until recently) couldn’t be found as a well-edited, entire-song piece.  A few days ago, the Grammys finally released it:

I’m not the first to comment on being moved not only by the song but also the joy at seeing Chapman perform and the joy at seeing another artist play and sing along with her.   The look on both their faces (and of many in the audience) is amazing and probably the best any artist could ask for.  Quite the quiet but powerful moment, really.

Posted in Music, The Long Story | Leave a comment

“Where My Feet Are”

I discovered this recently recorded song by Andrew Peterson thanks to the comments section for this article from Mockingbird.

A few years ago, I started encouraging our students with “wherever you are, be all there,” especially if we were at camp.  I can’t remember the source of the saying, but I’m grateful for wherever it came from.  This song is that statement as a prayer.

P.S.  The Mockingbird article is good, too.  Maybe I’ll get around to saying more about it soon.

Posted in Faith, Life in the Fifth Act, Music, Teaching, The Long Story | Tagged | Leave a comment

Remembrance Part One

Varden LonelinessErik Varden’s The Shattering of Loneliness begins with a Lenten reflection.  The book consists of six pieces, with each piece focusing on a different truth that Christians are called to remember.  The first ties into Ash Wednesday: remember you are dust.

The call to remember that we are dust is one of the best places to start any journey towards Easter.  It is a callback to the beginning of Genesis and therefore to the beginning of all things, ourselves included.

Then the Lord God formed a man from the dust of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living being. [NIV]

It also acts as a thread that carries over into the “second act” of the Biblical Story, where Adam and Eve eat the fruit and realize they are naked and then are told by God that

19 By the sweat of your brow
you will eat your food
until you return to the ground,
since from it you were taken;
for dust you are
and to dust you will return.” [NIV]

Ash Wednesday, which begins the Lenten season for many Christians, is a call to remember that we are dust but should also remind us that we are oh so much more, which is by the design of our Creator.

+ + + + + + +

Varden has a lot to say about our “dusty disposition” that’s worth a read.  All of it is good encouragement to remember something significant about the human condition.  He writes:

This sentence is sometimes called “the curse of Adam.”  It is a misnomer.The Lord’s words do not condemn. They simply state a fact.By acting as he did, disregarding the precept, Adam preferred his criteria to those of his Maker.  He, who, at first, had stood face to face with the flaming countenance of God, whose being reflected God’s glory, yielded to presumption. He thought he subsisted at God’s level by some quality intrinsic to himself . . .  He forgot that his spiritual nature was given him by grace, the biblical word for a gift that is gratuitous and free, which no effort or deserving can obtain. (15-16)

He has much to say about the linguistic connection with being from the earth and the virtue of humility.  He reminds the reader that “For a Christian, spiritual growth presupposes rootedness in matter” (19-20).  Our tall towers and planet-leaving imaginations must and should always be brought back “down to earth” in a way.  And yet our “dusty disposition” calls us to something greater in another way:

Dust though we are, we can never find rest in being nothing but dust, having known the gentle touch of God’s fingers. (21)

Such a great image, both humbling and uplifting!  One other thought for now about being dust and knowing the “gentle touch of God’s fingers”:

A human being is dust called to glory.  To remain in that tension is a challenge.  It takes time and strength of purpose to be reconciled to it.  To accept that my nature is defined by a sense of incompletion so vast that it cannot be repaired within the order of creation— not by any possession, any accomplishment, any relationship— is to embrace radical poverty.  I know the the fulfillment of my being can only come from outside myself, as a gift. I cannot heave myself up to the heights I long to reach.  But I can be carried there. (21-22)

+ + + + + + +

One of my goals for the next few weeks is to post a weekly reflection on each chapter of The Shattering of Loneliness, which should lead up nicely to Easter.  I should’ve written and posted this entry earlier, but the end of last week was busier than I had anticipated.  I’ll likely revisit some of what Varden said about “our dusty disposition” in the second post.  He has much more to say about God’s goodness and human nature: he does an impressive job weaving in thoughts and reflections from literature, the visual and performing arts, and the lives of various saints, monks, and nuns.  Remembering that we are dust touched by glory, though, is a great place to start.

Posted in Books, Faith, Holidays, Scripture, The Long Story | Tagged | Leave a comment